City Mouse

I’ve been aware of the urban-rural divide ever since I read City Mouse-Country Mouse, but this graphic of the last election really put things in perspective:

results2004_lg

Found while reading this post by Ed Stephan at The Carpetbagger, which has some other useful links. And this chart:

cb.urban

This really seems like the strongest argument I’ve seen yet for eliminating the electoral college, which continues to give rural areas a disproportionate percentage of the vote.

(via Political Animal)

{, , , , }

If you enjoyed this post, please consider to leave a comment or subscribe to the feed and get future articles delivered to your feed reader.

Comments

I don’t know, bro. Isn’t one of the founding ideas of the Republic to create certain balances? The Senate and the House of Representatives, the very idea of rights for minorities to protect them from majority dictatorship… There needs to be a balance between population and geography. That image, actually, made me less virulently anti-electoral college. Although the electoral college may give rural areas a disproportionate vote, Bush still did win the popular vote, so ditching the EC wouldn’t have really changed anything, this time around.

I’m interested in the anomalies: Without really knowing, I would guess that the blue rural areas in the Southwest (including Texas) are areas with large Mexican-American populations. But what’s with the blue banks of the Mississippi? Or that blue swatch in the middle of Alabama? Did Sherman make that?

The electoral college was designed not to prevent the tyranny of the majority, but as a compromise with the slave owning aristocracy in the South. And while it is true that Bush won the popular vote, it is important to remember that the campaigns would have been very different if they weren’t strategizing over the electoral college - catering to rural interests.

I imagine the blue banks of the Mississippi represents were the African American population lives. Same with Alabama.

Sorry, the comment form is closed at this time.